Caffeinated Politics

Opinions, Musings By Gregory Humphrey


When Pragmatism Is Tossed Aside: Chicago Mayor Brandon Johnson Must Be Replaced In 2027

Perhaps it comes from reading history, or from my work in local politics and state government, but at all levels, pragmatism is essential for leaders to employ and for citizens to understand as the basis for shaping policy. When pragmatism is not employed, things go off a cliff, and quickly. Take, for example, what is happening in Chicago due to Mayor Brandon Johnson’s actions.

Watching him underperform at almost every juncture over four years has been funny at times and shocking at others. Having grown up with Chicago radio as a teenager and never leaving the city’s events over decades of adulthood, I’m very aware of the sharp-elbowed politics in the Windy City. But Johnson’s lack of professionalism and any sense of how to guide a boat into the harbor from the frothy political lake is truly beyond anything I have seen from another Chicago mayor. Johnson is the most ineffective and amateurish elected official in a major city today. Being a social warrior is not enough reason to be elected.

September 28th.

Johnson a year ago pitched a $21-per-employee tax on companies with more than 100 employees; negotiations at one point moved it to a $33-per-employee monthly tax on companies with more than 500 Chicago employees. Ultimately, aldermen voted it down in a committee meeting.

October 22nd

The job of mayor is, at its core, a management task. In the Johnson administration, that has taken a back seat to extracting cash from those deemed by these redistributionists as having too much of it. Continuing this quixotic hunt for the socialistic holy grail is not acceptable, even in an election year. It’s irresponsible. Whatever your politics.

So, fellow Chicagoans, fasten your seatbelts and prepare for the wildest, most unnerving rollercoaster ride of the four budget cycles that have comprised the city’s Brandon Johnson Experience. We found last year’s twister, in which Johnson took the city to the brink of an unheard-of government shutdown in order to tax large corporate employers for the very jobs they provide in the city, to be plenty unpleasant enough.

Speaking of that so-called head tax, Johnson failed to win City Council approval, but it’s ba-aaack despite a substantial majority of aldermen informing City Hall in a public letter just weeks ago they wouldn’t support it if he trotted it out again.

October 29th

Gov. JB Pritzker on Thursday reiterated his opposition to a per-employee corporate tax in Chicago, as Mayor Brandon Johnson again proposes one as part of his latest city budget pitch.

“I do not think that is a great way to provide revenue for the city, and here’s why: it sends a signal. It’s just the most direct signal to employers: don’t hire more people,” Pritzker said when asked about the idea of a so-called “head tax,” which the mayor has included in his city spending package for the second year in a row.

November 12th

Here’s the reality: A substantial council majority has said unequivocally that they won’t vote for Johnson’s $336 million in these two tax hikes, which fall principally on Chicago businesses. Having staked this ground firmly, this majority can’t afford to give in now, at least in political terms. That means Johnson must do something else to plug that chunk of the $882 million deficit facing the city next year.

Best get on that, Mr. Mayor.

At this point, Chicago voters well understand Johnson’s budget preferences as he seeks a second term in next year’s election. Mission accomplished on the political branding front.

But what Chicago actually needs most of all is a low-drama budget that protects the city’s credit and access to the bond markets. That then would allow a debate over Chicago’s future to take place without more financial damage done.

And serious prior damage indeed has been done by this mayor.

November 17th

Mayor Brandon Johnson brushed aside his former chief financial officer’s accusations of his administration pressuring her to report inaccurate financial information as a “technical” dispute Tuesday.

In his first appearance at a regularly scheduled City Hall news conference since CFO Ashlee Gabrysch’s sudden exit Friday, Johnson told reporters her concerns about the city’s deficit reporting and characterization of settlement borrowing were moot because his administration ultimately ended up presenting her figures in budget documents.

“First of all, the technical difference of interpretation on what was structural and what was not was actually worked out in a very thoughtful and engaged conversation,” Johnson said.

The mayor would repeat the word “technical” five times as he sought to play down the clash that sparked a City Council backlash which threatens to upend his efforts to pass a budget for 2027. Gabrysch resigned Friday, saying in a statement to the Tribune, “It has become apparent… that to continue in this role would be to compromise my integrity and professional obligations.”

November 18th

Aldermen overwhelmingly passed an ordinance giving themselves the power to investigate Mayor Brandon Johnson’s handling of city finances Wednesday following the controversial resignation of his chief financial officer.

Johnson opponents said they need the authority because of the abrupt departure of CFO Ashlee Gabrysch, who cited a refusal to “compromise my integrity” as she left the mayor’s team after only three months in the key position. The acrimonious exit raises doubts about basic parts of Johnson’s latest budget proposal, they argued.

“We can’t put our fiscal house in order until we know the foundation is sound,” downtown Ald. Bill Conway said. “Regardless of whether you think there is misconduct or not, it is important that we conduct such a review in light of recent allegations.”

It was an attempt to wrest control from Johnson amid the chaos on his finance and budget team. While several progressives rallied behind the audit, a handful of the mayor’s closest allies blasted it as wasteful political theater. After a bitter floor debate that revisited many old grievances, the City Council voted 45-5 to approve the review.



Leave a Reply