Caffeinated Politics

Opinions, Musings By Gregory Humphrey


Learning What We Don’t Know

This afternoon, with sunshine and 66 degrees on the isthmus, James and I sat outside at Collectivo Coffee. On November 21st! That alone is reason to smile aplenty. But a paragraph in First Great Triumph by Warren Zmmerman made me sit back and feel infinitely good inside. A truth recorded in the 1800s by Henry Cabot Lodge speaks to our needs in the 21st century.

Henry Adams is teaching medieval history at Harvard. In the classroom sits Cobot Lodge and will write later, “Mr. Adams roused the spirit of inquiry and controversy in me…He had the power not only of exciting interest, but he awakened opposition to his own views…For the first time I got a glimpse of what education might be.” Lodge is the ideal of what people should aspire to be. Not sitting in a Harvard classroom, per se, but the willingness to expand personal thinking and then embrace the facts and reason education takes us to.

Since the Tea Party conservatives took the national stage following the election of our first African-American president and found Sarah Palin a beacon of reason, and following the absolute lunacy of MAGA and Donald Trump becoming Dear Leader, I have seriously questioned how people come to their views. Needless to say, I have often had to shake my head and walk away from many conversations. But the foundation of my interest remains.

When someone holds a factless policy view or a wide array of unhinged, irrational views, how does reason break through? And what happens when a sizable segment of the nation is bedeviled with such people? What happens when people are unwilling or unable to examine the points where facts clash with their upside-down opinions?

You and I know that a policy debate only works when the people in it share a basic respect for evidence. When MAGA presents slogans, viral posts, and tribal loyalty instead of data, there is nothing to argue over, because no claim can be tested. Democracy needs citizens who want to learn, test their assumptions, and meet ideas that challenge them. Without that, politics turns into a contest of grievances. Welcome to the world of right-wing conservatives in America.

This evening, let me narrow it down to an issue that simply frustrates me. In many rural areas, such as where I grew up in Hancock, Wisconsin, there is enough lousy, demeaning xenophobia with an anti-Muslim stench that it reaches across the state. Pew data shows 76% of Republicans who live in these small towns with lower college rates and economic headwinds say Islam promotes violence. The rate of hate has increased because Trump has used tortured rhetoric for partisan reasons. Recall, if you will, how the gap in such hate was much lower right after 9/11, when President George W. Bush publicly called Islam a religion of peace.

A classroom would teach those rural rubes that anyone studying the history of Islam would discover a faith of well over a billion people, with a scholarly tradition spanning centuries, wide doctrinal and cultural diversity, and a long record of coexistence and intellectual achievement. But devoid of education, conservatives hold to caricatures of the actions of extremists, and hold tight to bigotry.

The remedy, as this column starts out, is to embrace education and question what we think we know. I am the first to stand up and say this was an avenue I took on several positions I had held. I started out as an adult, wedded to Congressman Richard Gephardt and his hardline protectionist trade positions. But as I worked in the state legislature, I could not square facts with my opinions. In a decade, I would be an advocate for free trade, where I stand today. Likewise, I had a 180-degree turn over the advisability of needle-exchange programs. My visceral reaction to drugs and drug users had to be pushed aside by the science and proven data for the efforts at preventing preventable diseases. Coming to terms with what we do not know is a process.

As I look up at my bookshelves this evening and think about the point I am trying to make, my eyes land on Frederick Douglass, who, in life, talked about learning to read as a turning point. That act exposed him to arguments against slavery and gave him words for what he had only felt. Or Malcolm X, who read eagerly to feel mentally alive. Those volumes he consumed led him to revise major beliefs about race and the possibility of cooperation across racial lines. A very public figure who said that more knowledge meant changing his mind. Or Tara Westover, who wrote in Educated about being raised in a survivalist family in rural Idaho with almost no formal schooling. She enters college at seventeen and eventually earns a PhD at Cambridge. Her central theme is that education let her weigh competing accounts of history and revise her convictions.

Education, at the end of the day, should challenge what we think we know.

P.S. If this was a bit long, I might add that I drank cold brew coffee today like a boy might kick back with soda in the summer.



Leave a Reply