Caffeinated Politics

Opinions, Musings By Gregory Humphrey


Your Muslim Neighbor, Co-Worker Is Not the Enemy

It was repellent to hear and watch the many instances of anti-Muslim fearmongering during the 2026 midterm election season. In small-town America, the hatred was dressed up as patriotism but rooted in the oldest of prejudices. In another election season, these same people would have been accusing Catholics of being secretly loyal to the pope rather than the Constitution. Before that, they would have portrayed Jewish Americans as foreign influencers. In other periods of our past, these nativists would have excoriated migrants from Ireland, Italy, China, Japan, and countless other places. But here is the thing. The faces painted as “the other” changed, but the foundation of stereotypes and unreasonable actions remains the same.

I was reading the Bulwark this morning about the GOP’s problem with those of the Islamic faith. There were several examples of the tone of conservatives’ responses, as shown below.

Here’s Michelle, 57, from Georgia:

I know that [Gov.-elect Keisha Lance Bottoms] is backed by several Muslim leaders around Atlanta, and we have to be careful as a nation who we’re allowing to become elected. . . . We don’t realize it’s like sleeper people are coming in. Ilhan Omar should never have been elected. Mamdani should never be the mayor of New York. I used to live in New York City, and I’m telling you, people are hurting there. They’re hurting in Michigan, in all these places where people that support sharia law [are in office].

I held my iPad tighter and wondered what it would take for someone to sit this woman down and have her listen to facts. American Muslims are not outsiders peering through the windows of democracy. They are veterans who served in uniform, physicians who save lives, teachers who educate children, business owners who create jobs, taxpayers who fund public services, and citizens who cast ballots like everyone else. Their constitutional rights do not come with an asterisk.

Right, Michelle? Right?

What makes me laugh outright is when the level of prejudice rises so that the far-right starts to talk about Sharia law. When they go there, it is particularly telling. For more than two decades, conspiracy-driven wackjobs and angry white male talk radio personalities have invoked the term as a political scarecrow, even though American law is governed by the Constitution and the courts, not religious doctrine. No mayor, governor, state legislator, or member of Congress possesses the power to replace the Constitution with a religious legal system. The claim survives not because it is credible, but because it taps into fear.

What floored me repeatedly over the past couple of election cycles is that candidates of the Islamic faith are supposedly to act differently leading up to an election. Imagine declaring that a Christian candidate should be distrusted because some Christian leaders endorsed them. Imagine arguing that a Jewish elected official is suspect because Jewish organizations support them. Americans would instantly recognize such reasoning as bigotry. Yet when the target is Muslim, thoughtless conservatives still attempt to pass prejudice off as prudence.

I would love to be filthy rich and rent a bunch of small aircraft to fly over rural America (my hometown of Hancock would be one location) with a banner flying in the breeze stating that the First Amendment protects freedom of religion precisely because the founders understood that governments and majorities cannot be trusted to be the arbiters of faith. (OK, I would need to tighten up the words, but you get the idea.)

I will leave this column with a question for my readers to ponder. How many generations must a family live here, how many taxes must they pay, how many businesses must they build, how many elections must they vote in, and how many sons and daughters must they send into military service before they are finally considered fully American?

In a nation dedicated to liberty and equality, the answer should be obvious. They already are.



Leave a Reply